Nat Love

Rufus Buck

Trudy Smith

Stagecoach Mary

Bass Reeves

Cuffee

Cherokee Bill

Bill Pickett

Jim Beckwourth

Wiley Escoe

Jesus Cortez

Monroe Grimes

Clyde Grimes

Angel

Biggest Man on the Train

General Abbott

Bank Teller

Cowboy

Lady of the Night

Lady of the Night

Prison Lieutenant

Bank Patron

Jake Abbott

Mr. Love

Eleanor Love

Young Nat

Lady of the Night

Eleanor Love

Prisoner Guard

Lady of the Night

Train Server

Train Passenger

Prison Guard

Shopkeeper

Maysville Citizen

Lady of the Night

Maysville Bank Manager

Woody

Maysville Citizen

Zeke

Father Esparza

Douglastown Cowboy (uncredited)

Blue Lady

Carson