Amsterdam Vallon

Bill "The Butcher" Cutting

Jenny Everdeane

Boss Tweed

Happy Jack

Johnny Sirocco

"Priest" Vallon

Walter "Monk" McGinn

McGloin

Shang

Killoran

Reverend Raleigh

Mr. Schermerhorn

Jimmy Spoils

Hell-Cat Maggie

P.T. Barnum

One-Armed Priest

Young Amsterdam

Young Johnny

O'Connell Guard Leader

Plug Uglies Leader

Shirt Tails Leader

Chichesters Leader

Forty Thieves Leader

Calvinist Minister

Bill The Butcher's Gang #1

Bill The Butcher's Gang #2

Bill The Butcher's Gang #3

True Blue American Speaker

Jenny's Girl

Jenny's Girl

Jenny's Girl

Resident Woman

Black Joke Chief

Resident Man

Dead Rabbit Gang Member

Dead Rabbit Gang Member

Chinese at Sparrow's Pagoda

Elderly Chinese at Pagoda

Satan's Circus Singer

Rat Pit Game Master

Card Player (Harvey)

Undertaker

Medical Student

Army Recruiter

Passenger on Omnibus

Mrs. Schermerhorn

Horace Greeley

Miss Schermerhorn

Street Singer

Assistant Hangman

Condemned Man (Arthur)

Condemned Man (Seamus)

Legless Soldier

She-He

Recruiter

Harry Watkins / Lincoln

Uncle Tom

Mr. Shelby

Mr. Legree

Topsy

Miss Eliza

Assassin

Tap Dancer

Chinese Whore

Whore #1

Whore #2

Chinese Acrobat

Chinese General

Chinese Dancer

Chinese Boy Singer

Knife Act Caller

Surgeon

Archbishop

Provost Marshal Registrar

Unruly Man

Don Whiskerandos

Nativist Candidate

One-Armed Veteran

Drunken Repeater

The Mayor

Draft Official

O'Connell Guard Leader

Plug Uglies Leader

Forty Thieves Leader

Kerryonians Leader

Chichesters Leader

American Guard Leader

Atlantic Guard Leader

Slaughter Housers Leader

Bowery Boys Leader

Bloodied Bureaucrat

Telegraph Operator #1 (voice)

Telegraph Operator #2 (voice)

Telegraph Operator #3 (voice)

Police Chief

Telegraph Operator

Robber on Dock

Woman Accomplice

General Wool

Gunboat Captain

Soldier in Mist

Wealthy Homeowner (uncredited)

Man in Tweed's Office (uncredited)

Bar Bouncer (uncredited)

Native (uncredited)

Citizen (uncredited)

Fireman (uncredited)

Tammany Man (uncredited)

Middle Class Man (uncredited)

Coach (uncredited)

Tweed's Whore (uncredited)

Priest's Gang Member (uncredited)

Rapist (uncredited)

Dead Rabbit Gang Member (uncredited)

Internee (uncredited)

Bill the Butcher's Gang Member (uncredited)

Bill the Butcher's Gang Member (uncredited)

Bill the Butcher's Gang Member (uncredited)

Bill the Butcher's Gang Member (uncredited)

Bill the Butcher's Gang Member (uncredited)

Priest's Gang Member (uncredited)