Sylvia Likens

Gertrude Baniszewski

Jennifer Faye 'Jennie' Likens

Lester Likens

Betty Likens

Paula Baniszewski

Stephanie Baniszewski

Johnny Baniszewski

Shirley Baniszewski

Prosecutor

Andy

Eric

Reverend Bill Collier

Marie Baniszewski

Hope Orbach

Coy Hubbard

Bradley

Patty

Teddy

Ricky Hobbs

Sally

Officer Waters

Bailiff

Mrs. Doyle

Cottin Candy Vendor (uncredited)

Defense Attorney (uncredited)

Newspaper Reporter (uncredited)

Carnie (uncredited)